“In the beginner's mind there are many possibilities, but in the expert's there are few." - Shunryo Suzuki, Zen master
Climate investing has come a long way. Investors now finally recognize the dangers of climate change and would like to fix it. It's given the impetus for companies to do something, and some companies have taken the lead. Meanwhile, standards for climate accounting and disclosures have been developed and starting to be utilized. Pathways for industries to be decarbonize have been researched and published. New technologies on the horizon offer at least the hope that we could reverse the damage before it's too late.
At the same time, there's much more that needs to be done. The ESG metrics used to guide climate investing have generally proven to be of limited value. The stampede into ESG funds happened before clear definitions of what an ESG fund really is. While companies are starting disclose their climate risk and strategies, the disclosures are often incomplete and inconsistent. Many companies are talking about climate, but they routinely reject calls to take action. Activist shareholders have even succeeded in electing directors on climate ballots, but we don't know how much influence they could ultimately exert.
2021 may turn out to be the peak of expectations for ESG investing. With a decade of outperformance, it seemed like a "have your cake and eat it too" time where climate investing was the same as profitable investing. Yet much of ESG investing was a shifting of assets from carbon intensive industries such as oil and gas to low carbon industries such as technology and healthcare. The resulting underpformance of oil and gas companies led to their having the lowest relative valuations of any major industry, prompting them to sell assets to private equity and other buyers. They also set the stage for a comeback rally that we're seeing now. This may cause a thinning out of the ESG space, both for fund managers and investors. Perhaps it would be a necessary step for us to move forward.
I hope in the next phase of climate investing some of these things will happen:
- Companies improve their climate disclosures. More companies disclose. They disclose all their Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions. The disclosures become consistent and understandable.
- With these disclosures, investors could understand companies' climate risks and strategies much better than with today's ESG scores.
- Investors would monitor companies' progress to on climate.
- Companies which are taking real action get favorable valuations from long-term, supportive investors.
- Carbon markets are fixed so that they could finally fund climate action at scale.
Each of these is big. We may decide to take on different challenges, but we must all act now to make them happen.
So that's all I have to tell you for now.
The book is unfinished, but as I said at the beginning, it never will be. This is a quest we're going on together, and now it's your turn. Use what I've given you as a starting point, but go out and find new and better ways to make the world and the financial markets better.
This book will never be finished because there are so many opportunities out there. So many crucial services are underfunded because we have not figured out how to make them a part of our financial markets. When I was a portfolio manager, I spent a lot of time with people who spent all day talking about how there were no opportunities left. In fact they just needed to get out of their ivory towers and look in the real world -- and get ready to do some real work. Climate, biodiversity, and nature are just a few important ones that we need to fix, and urgently so unless we're consumed by climate change in our own lifetimes.
Sometimes it might seem too hard to fix these problems. That there is too much inertia. But don't get discouraged. In time, smart people will make these things happen. The voluntary carbon offsets market, for example, is a fully functioning market for climate and nature. It is still tiny, but then again, it didn't exist a couple of decades ago. So change is possible. We've just got to work faster and bigger. But then that's what you're here for, isn't it?
I also take comfort in a couple of other thoughts. Looking over the long arc of history, healthcare and education once were unattainable luxuries except for the elites. Then they became charitable works and public goods. Now they are serviced by private industry and financed by the capital markets.
Why can't we do the same for climate and nature?
Of course, you've probably heard that the problem is that there's too many people, and we consume too much. Just remember people have been saying this for, well, ever. Apparently even the ancient Babylonians thought the world was getting overpopulated, 3700 years and 7.8 billion people ago. In recent times, yo've probably heard about Thomas Malthus, who in 1798 predicted that population growth would eventually exceed food production, leading to catastrophe. Think about how wrong he has been. For over 200 years (4000 years?), successive generations have innovated to create a world that supports more people with a far higher standard of living than he could've ever imagined.
Will we really be the first generation to fail?
We don't have to be.
Ultimately we'll live in the world we worked to create.
So let's get to work.
Sign up for our email newsletter to get updates on this book and the Open Climate Investing project.
This content is published for informational purposes only and not investment advice or inducement or advertising to purchase or sell any security. See full disclaimer.